Pipe Support Vibration Isolation: Rubber vs Spring Hangers
Share
Pipe support vibration isolation is essential in modern building and industrial systems to prevent noise, structural damage, and premature equipment failure.
Two of the most common solutions are rubber hangers and spring hangers.
This article provides a detailed, SEO-optimized comparison to help engineers, facility managers, and specifiers make informed decisions for their projects.
What is Pipe Support Vibration Isolation?
Vibration isolation in pipe supports involves using specialized hangers or mounts to reduce the transmission of vibratory energy from pipes to building structures and sensitive equipment. This is critical for:
- Protecting structures and equipment from vibration-induced damage
- Reducing noise and improving occupant comfort
- Complying with industry standards (e.g., ASHRAE, ASME) for safe and reliable piping systems.
Rubber Hangers: Features, Pros & Cons
Construction & Design
- Material: Oil-resistant neoprene or elastomeric rubber, encased in a steel bracket
- Design: Loads elastomer in shear for durability; accommodates up to 30° rod misalignment
- Deflection: 0.20"–0.57" (5–15 mm)
- Load Capacity: Up to 2,000 lbs (907 kg)
- Temperature Range: -20°C to +80°C
Performance
- Best for high-frequency vibration and noise isolation (above 10 Hz)
- High internal damping for noise reduction
- Minimal maintenance; periodic visual inspection recommended
Advantages
- Cost-effective for standard applications
- Simple, quick installation
- Robust, oil-resistant, and long-lasting in moderate environments
Limitations
- Less effective for low-frequency vibration (<10 Hz)
- Not suitable for very heavy or critical applications
- Sensitive to UV, ozone, and extreme temperatures.
Spring Hangers: Features, Pros & Cons
Types & Design
- Types: Coil spring, variable spring, and constant support hangers
- Material: High-deflection steel springs, often with powder-coated or plated housings
- Deflection: 1"–4" (25–102 mm) or more
- Load Capacity: 12–3,850 lbs (5–1,747 kg) and higher for heavy-duty models
- Temperature Range: -60°C to 250°C (standard); up to 500°C with special alloys.
Performance
- Superior for low-frequency vibration isolation (as low as 3–4 Hz)
- Wide load and deflection range for heavy-duty and critical applications
- Can be combined with elastomeric elements for broad-spectrum isolation
Advantages
- Excellent for heavy loads and large vertical movement (thermal expansion)
- High durability and fatigue life
- Fail-safe design with high overload capacity
Limitations
- Higher initial cost
- More complex installation and adjustment
- Requires periodic inspection and maintenance.
Rubber vs Spring Hangers: Direct Comparison
| Criteria | Rubber Hangers | Spring Hangers |
|---|---|---|
| Frequency Range | Best for >10 Hz (high-frequency) | Best for <10 Hz (low-frequency) |
| Damping | High (good for noise) | Low (combine with elastomer for high-frequency isolation) |
| Cost | Low to moderate | Moderate to high |
| Installation | Simple, quick | More complex, requires adjustment |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Regular inspection/adjustment |
| Lifespan | Good (moderate conditions) | Excellent (with proper material) |
| Environmental | Sensitive to UV, ozone, heat, chemicals | Wide temperature range, corrosion-resistant with coatings |
| Load Capacity | Moderate (up to 2,000 lbs) | High (up to 3,850 lbs or more) |
| Best For | Light/medium loads, high-frequency noise, cost-sensitive | Heavy loads, low-frequency vibration, critical applications |
How to Choose the Right Vibration Isolator
Selection Guidelines
-
Use rubber hangers
- High-frequency vibration/noise
- Light to medium loads
- Cost-sensitive or space-constrained projects
- Residential, light commercial, or fire protection systems
-
Use spring hangers
- Low-frequency vibration (e.g., near pumps, compressors)
- Heavy loads or large vertical movement (thermal expansion)
- Industrial, power plant, or critical HVAC applications
-
Use combination (spring + rubber) hangers
- Broad-spectrum vibration isolation (both low and high frequencies)
- Environments with both heavy equipment and noise-sensitive areas (e.g., studios, hospitals).
Industry Applications & Case Studies
| Industry/Application | Preferred Hanger Type | Example/Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Power Plants | Spring Hanger | Accommodates large thermal movement in steam lines |
| Chemical Processing | Spring Hanger | Required for lines with significant expansion/contraction |
| HVAC (Commercial/Industrial) | Spring Hanger | Superior low-frequency isolation for large equipment and ductwork |
| HVAC (Residential/Light) | Rubber Hanger | Cost-effective, easy to install, sufficient for moderate vibration |
| Fire Sprinkler Systems | Rubber Hanger | Lightweight, economical, meets code for non-critical vibration isolation |
| Recording Studios/Theaters | Spring + Rubber | Dual-stage isolation for maximum sound and vibration attenuation |
Conclusion
Selecting the right vibration isolation hanger is essential for the safety, comfort, and longevity of your piping system.
Rubber hangers offer a cost-effective solution for high-frequency noise and light-to-medium loads, while spring hangers provide superior low-frequency isolation and support for heavy-duty applications.
For the most demanding environments, combination hangers deliver the best of both worlds.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the main difference between rubber and spring hangers?
Rubber hangers are best for high-frequency vibration and noise, while spring hangers excel at isolating low-frequency vibration and supporting heavy loads.
Can I use rubber hangers for heavy industrial piping?
Rubber hangers are generally not recommended for very heavy or critical applications; spring hangers or combination types are preferred.
How often do I need to maintain these hangers?
Rubber hangers require minimal maintenance (periodic inspection). Spring hangers need regular inspection and occasional adjustment.
Are combination hangers worth the extra cost?
For environments with both low and high-frequency vibration, combination hangers provide superior performance and are often worth the investment.